Alternate lightweight building systems cannot compare with double skin clay brick construction

Information supplied by Corobrik

The general applicability of the comparative superior thermal performance claims made by various lightweight walled Alternative Building System providers, that assume their walling systems’ higher insulation values [R-values], relative to double skin clay brick walling, translate into superior thermal performance outcomes, is not supported by science and extensive thermal modelling of houses constructed with different wall types here in South Africa.

For South Africa’s climates, thermal modelling studies, supported by extensive empirical research in Australia, validate that while the R-value is a useful measure of thermal resistance of the wall itself, a walling material’s R???value is not representative of the thermal value for energy efficient house design properties of a material.

Notably, the research confirms thermal mass [naturally inherent in clay brick], as a critical thermal performance property for optimising thermal performance outcomes in South Africa’s climate, where well defined average diurnal temperature swings characterise all six major climatic zones. It is the ability of thermal mass to slowly absorb, store and release heat, in ways that insulated lightweight walling cannot, that make clay bricks valuable in optimising thermal comfort inside houses.

As to be expected, the thermal modelling studies of both 130 m² and 40 m² low cost house types here in South Africa, that are consistent with the findings of 7 years of empirical research undertaken at the Priority Research Centre for Energy at the University of Newcastle in Australia, reinforce the validity of the latest WSP Energy Africa CR Product research, that if homes of the future are to achieve energy reduction targets, external walls must contain reasonable levels of thermal capacity, supplemented by varying levels of thermal resistance depending on the climatic zone. Clay brick brings both properties to the table most cost effectively. Lightweight walls can only bring resistance, and resistance on its own led to sub-optimal thermal performance outcomes for heating and cooling internal spaces in all the studies.

Adding further to this Dr Alec Johannsen of Alec Johannsen Consulting Engineering, in his review of the WSP Energy Africa CR Product study, noted: “There is an additional advantage of heavier walls (not discussed in the CR Product report as it is outside its scope), namely a reduction of the building peak cooling and heating loads.”

“This is the combined result of a reduction in the peak heat gain of the wall itself, and a time lag of the peak heat flux on the inside of the wall in relation to the heat flux on the outside, which makes the heat load from the wall out of phase with the other heat loads, resulting in a lower combined peak total heat load.”

“The result is a smaller and less expensive cooling and heating plant and a lower electrical demand. The above would indicate that greater ‘Cs’ (thermal capacity) should be favoured over ‘Rs’ (resistance) when selecting a required CR Product.”

South Africa’s benchmark construction methodology provides for optimal thermal outcomes, and cost effectively too. That face brick incurs no future carbon debt adds further environmental value to clay brick walling and drives lowest Life Cycle Costs.

Issued by Corobrik Marketing – 11 August 2010

Tel: 031 560 3111

Fax: 031 565 1532

Previous story
keyboard_arrow_upHarnessing air to heat water
keyboard_arrow_downHarnessing air to heat water

Stiebel Eltron’s WWK300AH heat pump is the most efficient domestic heat pump on the market

Next story
keyboard_arrow_upSwimming in colour
keyboard_arrow_downSwimming in colour

PoolCrete is recommended for the interior plastering of walls and floors of new and old swimming pools. It provides a thick smooth plaster which becomes a very hard and integral part of the pool structure

keyboard_arrow_upOld Mutual Cape Town will go “off the water grid” with launch of water filtration plant
keyboard_arrow_downOld Mutual Cape Town will go “off the water grid” with launch of water filtration plant

Earlier this week, Old Mutual’s Mutualpark office in Pinelands, Cape Town, one of the largest corporate offices in South Africa, officially launched the very first corporate based waste-to-drinking Water Filtration Plant in South Africa.  This means the 166 000m² office, currently accommodating more than 9 000 employees and contractors, is now operating off the water […]

keyboard_arrow_upDécor Trend Alert: Feature Ceilings
keyboard_arrow_downDécor Trend Alert: Feature Ceilings

The ceiling is a space in your home that is often overlooked (irony intended), but have you ever thought of what a key accent it could be in your space? We’re talking, sophisticated, unique feature ceilings that can transform your home space. We chatted to Cemcrete, who recently launched their selection of ceiling coatings to […]

keyboard_arrow_upITC-SA awards to recognise excellence in timber construction industry
keyboard_arrow_downITC-SA awards to recognise excellence in timber construction industry

The Institute for Timber Construction South Africa (ITC-SA), SAQA-accredited professional body and watchdog for South Africa’s timber construction trade, will be hosting its much-anticipated Annual Timber Engineered Product Awards in Cape Town on the 27th of July 2018.